Bayer Leverkusen CEO Fernando Carro recently revealed that Florian Wirtz’s summer move could have gone very differently. According to him, the young German might have joined Real Madrid instead of Liverpool — if Xabi Alonso had more control over transfers in Spain. “If Xabi had his way, Wirtz would definitely be at Madrid,” Carro told Sport1. “But at Real, Florentino Pérez makes the decisions — not Alonso.”
In the end, Wirtz had three major options: Manchester City, Bayern Munich, and Liverpool. After careful thought, he chose Anfield. But as Liverpool prepare to face City in one of the Premier League’s biggest games, the 22-year-old might be wondering if he chose wisely.
Why Liverpool Over City?
Wirtz was drawn to Liverpool’s rich history, top-class facilities, and passionate fan base. He was particularly impressed by the electric atmosphere during the Reds’ title celebrations last May. “I just wanted to be part of this team,” he told the club’s media.
But it wasn’t just emotion that guided his choice — it was Arne Slot’s tactical vision. The Dutchman presented a clear plan: Wirtz would be the creative hub behind the striker, orchestrating Liverpool’s attacks. However, that plan hasn’t unfolded as expected. A dip in form and tactical reshuffles have left the German struggling for rhythm and consistency.
Tactical Struggles and Harsh Judgments
Wirtz started Liverpool’s first four Premier League matches but failed to record a goal or assist. His lack of output drew criticism from fans and pundits alike.
Wayne Rooney offered a blunt assessment: “I think Wirtz actually damages the balance of Liverpool and how they play,” he said. “He’s a top player, but I just don’t see where he fits into their 4-3-3. If I have to choose between him and Szoboszlai, I pick Szoboszlai.”
Rooney’s remarks echo a wider sentiment: Wirtz’s adaptation to the intensity of English football has been tougher than expected.
Outshined by Szoboszlai
Ironically, the player Wirtz was brought in to surpass has been Liverpool’s standout performer. While Wirtz is still searching for his first contribution, Szoboszlai has already scored twice and provided four assists, including a stunning free-kick against Arsenal.
Slot now trusts his established trio — Szoboszlai, Ryan Gravenberch, and Alexis Mac Allister — leaving Wirtz on the fringes for now.
Would Man City Have Been a Better Fit?
Pep Guardiola had long admired Wirtz and saw him as the ideal De Bruyne successor. With his blend of creativity and work ethic, Wirtz would have slotted naturally into City’s structured but expressive 4-1-4-1 formation.
Reports differ on why the move didn’t happen — some say City were unwilling to meet Leverkusen’s £100m asking price, while others suggest Wirtz was hesitant because Guardiola couldn’t commit beyond 2027.
Meanwhile, Rayan Cherki — City’s eventual signing for £30m — has already recorded eight goal involvements, looking every bit the bargain.
Final Thoughts
Liverpool’s decision to invest heavily in Wirtz was bold and forward-thinking, but it hasn’t yet paid off. The German playmaker has the potential to shine in England — yet he must find his confidence and role in Slot’s dynamic midfield.
His journey is far from over, but it stands as a lesson in timing and transition: sometimes the right player can find himself in the wrong system. The upcoming clash with Manchester City might be his best chance yet to prove he belongs on England’s biggest stage.